jnewland

Mena Trott asks: Are Productive Online Conversations Possible?

In Mena Trott’s apologetic follow-up to her implosion at Les Blogs (video here) she poses a question to the blogosphere:

Is it possible to have the sort of productive face-to-face connection or conversation that Ben M. and I had offline in an online world? And what can we, as bloggers, do to facilitate that?

Here’s my take, Mena:

Yes, it is possible to have deep, exciting, terrifying, enlightening, and (most of all) productive conversations online. I’ve had many.

How do bloggers facilitate this? I’m sure not we all can: to facilitate the spread of productive conversation, bloggers must lead by example. This, in my mind, requires four things:

  1. Being able to respecfully, productively communicate in person
  2. Believing that we can conduct a similarly productive repore on the intraweb
  3. Taking care and caution to stip the non-productive bits from your online communication (this post was a great excersize of item #3), and lastly
  4. Taking even greater care when reponding to criticism, or to ideas or opinions you disagree with.

I, for a start, pledge to behave reasonably and productively in all off- and on-line discussion regarding this issue. I believe that I can. I believe we all can.

Thoughts, anyone?